Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Social Networking and Privacy Concerns



The Backdrop
            Ever since the advent of internet and the associated cyber activities, questions of privacy of data have been discussed and analysed at various forums and levels.  Sometimes it is wrongly argued that social networking sites are replete with issues of privacy of data but e-mail service, use of mobile phone, internet etc do not have such issues.  At the outset it is better to have a proper understanding of the term privacy in the context of cyber activities. A clear misconception is so prevalent that the ‘unauthorised access and use of data kept private by the user’ and the ‘access and use of data made public by the user’ are wrongly considered as one and the same.
            For instance, at Face book, users may keep some data (mobile number etc) as private while some other data as public (employer details, native place etc). There will be not be any access to the former while everybody who log into Face book  can access the latter. It is simply plain that both are not same entities.  But there is a propensity to consider both as same phenomenon and whenever problems happen with them they are often wrongly referred with the term ‘privacy issues’.
            Again, with e-mail service, the contact details etc are kept as private by default but some data is made public (not by the user)  due to the lapses of software involved (like rough idea about  location from which the mail has been sent).
            As a matter of fact, in simple terms, privacy of data means the user who generated the data has complete control over its accessibility. No other person, other than the persons permitted by the original user, can access it in any manner. If access to the data is available to others who do not have the legitimate right from the original user, it would amount to lack of privacy of data.  It is also considered as an intrusion into the private data.
            On the other hand, ‘access and use of data made public by the user’ by any other person cannot be considered as an attack or intrusion into the privacy. If the data are made public by the user himself and are used by any other person even with a malicious intent, it can only be considered as ‘misuse of data’. There is absolutely no attack or intrusion into the privacy  as there was no ‘privacy of data’ even before the further usage of data! The data has been, knowingly or unknowingly, made public by the user himself and nothing is private there.  Further usage of public data by anybody else hence cannot be considered as privacy intrusion. The most that can be said about this phenomenon is that it is a misuse of data!
            To recapitulate, the ‘unauthorised access and use of data kept private by the user’ will become a privacy issue whereas the ‘access and use of data made public by the user’ by anybody else with a malicious intent will amount to misuse of data and the further ‘access and use of data made public by the user’ by anybody else with a bona fide intent will be considered as usage of data. It is worth noting the fact that ‘privacy issue of data’ and ‘misuse of data’ are two altogether different concepts.
            The fundamental distinction between ‘issue of privacy of data’ and ‘misuse of data made public by the user’ is that the former is associated with the various errors in the software used to generate and transfer data where as the latter is associated with the indiscriminate disclosure of data by the user. Theoretically, the latter has no relationship with the soft wares involved in the process. Many a times the indiscriminate disclosure of data by the user is a consequence of lack of awareness among users regarding the possibilities of misuse of revealed data. The table given below summarises the kernel of the discussion.


Sl. No.
Issue
Reason/Consequence
1
Unauthorised access and use of data kept private by the user
Errors in the software/Privacy  Questions
2
Access and use of data made public by the user by other with a malicious intent
Indiscriminate disclosure of data/Misuse of data
3
Access and use of data made public by the user by other with a bona fide intent
Use of data
  


Software Environment and Errors
            In a digital world, every digital activity is accomplished by using appropriate soft wares. Soft wares in general can be broadly categorized into three; system soft ware, programming soft ware and application soft ware. Notwithstanding these distinctions, software is nothing but a set of instructions or commands written in a particular language with an express purpose of accomplishing a specific task by utilizing the machine power of a computer.
            The most popular softwares that are familiar for the user community are operating system soft wares (UNIX, Linux, Windows, Sybian, Android et. al) and application soft wares (Office applications etc). These soft wares are often installed in the devises that we use. However, in the cyber world when we communicate or interact with others, we are taking the help of application soft wares that are not installed in our own systems. The e-mail service (provided by Gmail, Rediff, Yahoo et.al) and the social networking service (provided by Face book, Google plus, Twitter et.al) are in fact services provided by ‘application soft wares’ installed in the server computers of the providers.

            Furthermore there is absolutely no conceptual difference between the software that provides email service and social networking service. The differences between them depend only upon their differences in purpose.  The former does not provide the user any option to make the various components public where as the latter does provide options to make them public or private according to the preference of the user.
            As mentioned above software is nothing but a set of instructions or commands written in a particular language. In a broad sense, it can be likened to a document with several words, lines, paragraphs and pages. Every document contains multifarious types of errors and can be refined by continuously editing and revising it. Remember,  there is no end for the process of editing and revising as new perspectives, ideas etc emerges continuously.
            Similarly every software contain innumerable errors popularly called as software bugs caused by errors committed by the programmers in the source code and its design or caused by the compilers that generate erroneous source codes.  Some bugs make the software (system software or application soft ware) crash-prone or unstable while others make the software unsecure by wide opening pathways that could be exploited by a malicious user to bypass the access controls which eventually facilitate him to have control over the data stored in the application.
            As pointed out above, as in the case of a document, these software errors can be completely rectified only asymptotically. In simple terms it means that these software errors could be completely wiped off only after infinite number of editing and revising. In a practical sense, it implies that every software contain errors that could be exploited by a malicious user! (In the after math of Julian Assange episode it is highly wrong to refer every user who exploits the software errors as malicious user!)
            It is this unauthorized access and control over the data by a malicious user by exploiting the errors in a software, be it an operating system software or an application software,  that causes concerns of privacy. It is referred as ‘privacy concern’ just because of the reason that the data kept by the user is considered as ‘private’ and ‘personal’ to the legitimate user. Since these errors could be rectified only asymptotically, every software invariably contain errors and hence have ‘problems with respect to the security of the data’ popularly referred as ‘privacy concerns’.
E-Mail Service, Social Networking sites and Privacy Concerns
            It has been mentioned above that both e-mail service and social networking sites are provided by application soft wares running in the servers of respective providers. Since they are soft wares, just because of the reasons cited above, they invariable contain errors and are unsecure to that extend and hence have privacy issues.
            Sometimes it is argued that e-mail is secure but social networking sites are unsecure and have privacy questions attached with them. In the light of the facts narrated above it is easy to see that such arguments are made without understanding the basic and fundamental ideas underpinning software applications! If it is a software it will certainly contain errors and always prone to privacy concerns. There is no get away avenue even for the e-mail service from the questions of privacy (Any number of stories can be cited for this.). If anybody has a pathological concern towards privacy questions he must better keep away not only from social networking spaces but from e-mail service, use of mobile phone (because it also functions with the help  of software), internet surfing etc as well!
Social Networking sites, Openness and Misuse of Data
            The basic tenet of social networking is that the user must keep at least some personal information public. Otherwise it will amount only to private networking. If every data generated by the user is kept as private, in that space there would not be any scope for interaction. Hence in the social networking space users maintain some amount of personal data public.
            But once you make data public it would facilitate a malicious user to exploit and manipulate it. But even this avenue can be controlled by making appropriate changes in the ‘privacy settings’ so that the social networking space can be converted into a ‘limited networking’ space with access only to friends alone.  If the settings of access of  user data is increasingly made available within a limited circle,  the ‘limited networking’ activity would march more towards private networking!
            This is a dilemma that if access to every data is made increasingly limited to avoid misuse of data it would become ‘private networking’ where as if data is made public and ‘social networking’ is attempted it would open up avenues of misuse! As a matter of fact, this dilemma is a flimsy one and will vanish away once the user discern and realise the consequences of his own cyber behaviour. Social networking is something like talking in the public and if the misuse of whatever talked in public is to be avoided better not to talk sensitive things in public. It does not mean that you should not talk at all in public and one should talk only within home or in private. In fact, this is what every person is practising in his own daily life. 
No rational person would keep silent just because of the fear that there is possibility of misuse if anything is said in public, instead he would make use of his cerebral power and became vocal in a sensible manner! In fact the cyber world also needs a sensible person with a discerning behaviour.
Recapitulation
            Questions of privacy of data are related to errors in software and it has nothing to do with the malicious use of ‘data made public by the user himself’. The latter can be considered only as ‘misuse of data’. Since the misuse of data is made possible by the user himself by making his data public it could be easily dealt with by adopting a sensible cyber behavior.  But if anybody has  a pathological concern with the privacy of data, since it originates from the errors of a software, better not to use any cyber space or digital devise, be it e-mail, social networking, internet surfing, mobile phone etc.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Political Interests of Abdul Kalam and the ‘Dream’ for Subservience: The Wiki leaks Expose


 Wiki leaks accessed by The Hindu (18th March, 2011) revealed that the former President APJ Abdul Kalam informed the then US ambassador David C Mulford that he too had met with the then opposition leader LK Advani to make a shift in his opposition against  Indo-US nuclear deal. This news item has indeed casted a shadow upon the integrity of the office Indian President.
According to the Article 74 of the Indian Constitution the Indian President may act according to the advice given by the council of ministers. The full text of the
Article 74 is given below:  “Council of Ministers to aid and advise President.—(1) There shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and advise the President who shall, in the exercise of his functions, act in accordance with such advice: Provided that the President may require the Council of Ministers to reconsider such advice, either generally or otherwise, and the President shall act in accordance with the advice tendered after such reconsideration. (2) The question whether any, and if so what, advice was tendered by Ministers to the President shall not be inquired into in any court.”
Still the President have some discretionary powers but they all are related to the appointment of Prime Minister when no party have any clear majority, to explore the options of government formation when the ruling government looses majority, to disqualify a member of legislature, returning the advice of council of ministers or a bill passed by the parliament and to pocket veto (the time delaying tactics). Apart from these, nowhere it is stated that the President has discretionary powers and can engage in activities that are independent of the advice of the council of ministers or can engage in any kind of lobbying of sorts.

But the Wiki leaks accessed by The Hindu (18th March, 2011) showcased that the former President APJ Abdul Kalam informed the then US ambassador David C Mulford that he too had met with the then opposition leader LK Advani to make a shift in his opposition against  Indo-US nuclear deal.
 Why should the President APJ Abdul Kalam get worried about the political position taken by the Leader of Opposition?  The Leader of Opposition is supposed to reflect and air the views and concerns of general public and he is duty bound for that. The President is also constitutionally duty bound to ensure that all the organs and the various functionaries of the State are performing in a free and fair manner for the success of Indian democracy.  The Indian president is not supposed to lobby to change or influence the stand or position of anybody while occupying the real estate of Rashtrapathi Bhavan. And the Indian President is not supposed to divulge anything related to the opinion making process to an ambassador of any nation, let alone the ambassador of United States. 
But miserably, the former Indian president APJ Abdul Kalam, by forgetting or bypassing  all the above  mentioned  responsibilities and proprieties, engaged in lobbying of sorts and tried to influence  the then leader of opposition, LK Advani, to change his opposition against the Indo US nuclear deal for just to further  the  interests of the United States. The full text of the news coverage of The Hindu is given at the end. (See also: http://bit.ly/hjYcUa )
If the Wiki leaks accessed by The Hindu are true, it would be a highly unbecoming behavior from a person who occupied such a coveted apex constitutional position. If it is a fact, the alleged opinion making efforts from the former President would denigrate and demean the sanctity of the office of Indian President. The nation already witnessed several instances of politicking   from several former Presidents, but the cited politicking by APJ Abdul Kalam is the very first incident that came to the surface in acquiescence to the interests of a foreign nation (United States) and that too by the so called supreme commander of the nation! What a dream run for subservience in the US Kitchen!
The full text of the news coverage is given below:

U.S. plays politics for nuclear deal, woos BJP at cost of UPA coalition
Sarah Hiddleston
Washington was so keen on a nuclear deal with India that its New Delhi Embassy worked to “put Sonia Gandhi in a box” by wooing the opposition BJP and breaking the coalition with the Left parties, an Embassy cable sent on May 16, 2008, ( 154231, confidential) has revealed.
Ambassador David C. Mulford reported on a “carefully timed” approach to BJP leader L.K. Advani that he made in early May 2008. He urged Advani to “exhibit statesmanship and either back the nuclear deal or withdraw opposition to it”.

In the cable, Mulford also scripted out a rationale that the BJP could use to present its volte-face. The “possible script” included the BJP agreeing that it was a “good” overall deal and that it was “in the larger national interest,” and the possible enactment of the BJP's own Hyde Act if and when it came to power.
A new BJP posture, Mr. Mulford knew, would put the UPA in a spot: “It would … put Sonia Gandhi in a box; if she goes ahead with the deal, her Communist allies would be livid, might pull out of the coalition and possibly not have anything to do with the Congress Party post-election. If she does not go ahead with the deal, she will be seen as having let India down when it faced a crucial choice in order to stay in power for just a few more months. If Sonia goes ahead with the deal, she can call the Communists' bluff secure in the knowledge the BJP is pro-deal.”
It appeared from the cable that Mr. Advani turned down the U.S. advances at this May 8 meeting, though Mulford was later informed by Foreign Secretary Shiv Shankar Menon that Advani was “glad he came”. The Ambassador also called upon former President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, who informed him that “he too had met with Advani to seek a shift in the BJP leader's thinking.”
“Embassy,” an undeterred Mr. Mulford told superiors in Washington, “will keep reaching out to BJP opinion shapers to see if we can provoke a shift in the party that could bring the civil nuclear issue to a head by the end of May.”

Monday, March 28, 2011

Abdul Kalam and WikiLeaks

WikiLeaks accessed by The Hindu (18th March, 2011) showcased that the former President APJ Abdul Kalam informed the then US ambassador David C Mulford that he too had met with the then opposition leader LK Advani to make a shift in his opposition to Indo-US nuclear deal. This news item has casted a shadow upon the integrity of the office of Indian President.

According to the Article 74 of the Indian Constitution the Indian President may act according to the advice given by the council of ministers. The full text of the Article 74 is given below: “Council of Ministers to aid and advise President.—(1) There shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and advise the President who shall, in the exercise of his functions, act in accordance with such advice: Provided that the President may require the Council of Ministers to reconsider such advice, either generally or otherwise, and the President shall act in accordance with the advice tendered after such reconsideration. (2) The question whether any, and if so what, advice was tendered by Ministers to the President shall not be inquired into in any court.”

Still the President have some discretionary powers but they all are related to the appointment of Prime Minister when no party have any clear majority, to explore the options of government formation when the ruling government looses majority, to disqualify a member of legislature, returning the advice of council of ministers or a bill passed by the parliament and to pocket veto (the time delaying tactics). Apart from these, anywhere it is stated that the President has discretionary powers and can engage in activities that are independent of the advice of the council of ministers or can engage in any kind of lobbying of sorts.

But the WikiLeaks accessed by The Hindu (18th March, 2011) showcased that the former President APJ Abdul Kalam informed the then US ambassador David C Mulford that he too had met with the then opposition leader LK Advani to make a shift in his opposition to Indo-US nuclear deal. Why should the President APJ Abdul Kalam get worried about the political position taken by the Leader of Opposition? The Leader of Opposition is supposed to reflect and air the views and concerns of general public and he is duty bound for that. The President is also constitutionally duty bound to ensure that all the organs and the various functionaries of the State are performing in a free and fair manner for the success of Indian democracy. The Indian president is not supposed to lobby to change the stand or position of anybody while occupying the real estate of Rashtrapathi Bhavan. And the Indian President is not supposed to divulge anything related to the opinion making process to an ambassador of any nation, let alone the ambassador of United States. But miserably, the former Indian president APJ Abdul Kalam, by forgetting or bypassing all the above mentioned responsibilities and proprieties, engaged in lobbying of sorts and tried to shift the opposition of LK Advani against the Indo US nuclear deal for just to further the interests of the United States. The full text of the news coverage is given at the end. (See also: http://bit.ly/hjYcUa)

If the WikiLeaks accessed by The Hindu are true, it would be a highly unbecoming behavior from a person who occupied such a coveted apex constitutional position. If it is a fact, the alleged opinion making efforts from the former President would denigrate and demean the sanctity of the office of Indian President. The nation already witnessed several instances of politicking from several former Presidents, but the cited politicking from APJ Abdul Kalam is the very first incident that came to the surface in acquiescence to the interests of a foreign nation (United States) and that too by the so called supreme commander of the nation!

The full text of the news coverage is given below:

U.S. plays politics for nuclear deal, woos BJP at cost of UPA coalition

Sarah Hiddleston (The Hindu, 18th March, 2011)

Washington was so keen on a nuclear deal with India that its New Delhi Embassy worked to “put Sonia Gandhi in a box” by wooing the opposition BJP and breaking the coalition with the Left parties, an Embassy cable sent on May 16, 2008, ( 154231, confidential) has revealed.
Ambassador David C. Mulford reported on a “carefully timed” approach to BJP leader L.K. Advani that he made in early May 2008. He urged Advani to “exhibit statesmanship and either back the nuclear deal or withdraw opposition to it”.

In the cable, Mulford also scripted out a rationale that the BJP could use to present its volte-face. The “possible script” included the BJP agreeing that it was a “good” overall deal and that it was “in the larger national interest,” and the possible enactment of the BJP's own Hyde Act if and when it came to power.

A new BJP posture, Mr. Mulford knew, would put the UPA in a spot: “It would … put Sonia Gandhi in a box; if she goes ahead with the deal, her Communist allies would be livid, might pull out of the coalition and possibly not have anything to do with the Congress Party post-election. If she does not go ahead with the deal, she will be seen as having let India down when it faced a crucial choice in order to stay in power for just a few more months. If Sonia goes ahead with the deal, she can call the Communists' bluff secure in the knowledge the BJP is pro-deal.”

It appeared from the cable that Mr. Advani turned down the U.S. advances at this May 8 meeting, though Mulford was later informed by Foreign Secretary Shiv Shankar Menon that Advani was “glad he came”. The Ambassador also called upon former President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, who informed him that “he too had met with Advani to seek a shift in the BJP leader's thinking.”

“Embassy,” an undeterred Mr. Mulford told superiors in Washington, “will keep reaching out to BJP opinion shapers to see if we can provoke a shift in the party that could bring the civil nuclear issue to a head by the end of May.”

Monday, November 29, 2010

Cover for bed-fellows (Niira Radia tape controversy)

The Hindu, the most respected and reputed newspaper in India (to this author), willy-nilly engaged in an act of providing cover to those editor-cum-shop owners (Barkha Dutt, Group Editor NDTV; Vir Sanghvi Editorial Director, Hindustan Times etc.) of Niira Radia tape controversy. Its editorial (Wednesday, Nov 24, 2010, See at: http://bit.ly/fRywtq)) re-dressed the disgraced media persons in the Niira Radia tape controversy just as “power players” and provided them safe escape at least in the real estate of The Hindu editorial! (See for example an excerpt from the editorial. “……The recent publication of officially intercepted phone conversations between a corporate lobbyist and a raft of politicians and power players in Delhi suggests…”) The editorial should have said that the officially intercepted phone conversations were between a corporate lobbyist and a raft of politicians, senior media persons and power players in Delhi.

The editor has every right to express whatever opinion he has but has no right at all to hide facts. It hid the fact that the conversations indeed included senior media persons. After, the media persons included in the conversation were re-dressed and categorized as just power players. Still, he can hide facts since he has the freedom to do that. But then it cannot be argued that he is fulfilling journalist duties and exercising rights of media. That editor who ever he may be, must be reminded that he is also engaging in a ‘lobbying’ of sorts, an activity he vehemently lashed through out in the editorial.

At the same time The Hindu needs to be congratulated for publishing the article of Priscilla Jebaraj, “The spotlight is on the media now” (See at: http://bit.ly/e7jIwH) in the same page where it published the editorial under scrutiny.

So there is a conflicting behavior. In the editorial, disgraced media persons were given a cover, but in the leader page article they were stripped off!

At the end of the day, the curiosity is to know what is the real opinion of The Hindu. Did it want to take a soft approach to their colleagues in other firms and at the very same time want to relay the strong message that they do not want to give a cover for those ‘editor-cum-shop owners’? But please, The Hindu, always remember that the editorial has more gravity!

The full text of the editorial is given below:

No reason to fear JPC

So enormous is the scale of the 2G spectrum scandal and so widely dispersed and influential are the dramatis personae that ordinary instruments of investigation may not be enough to get to the bottom of the affair. The report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India has come up with three key findings. First, that the Telecom Ministry under A. Raja deliberately ignored suggestions from other branches of government on the manner in which spectrum was to be allocated to new players in the 2G space. Second, that as a result the exchequer suffered a presumptive loss of anywhere between Rs.60,000 crore and Rs.179,000 crore. And third, that more than the factum or quantum of loss, the real scandal lies in the manner in which the first-come-first-served rules were re-jigged in order to cherry pick some companies for allocation. The recent publication of officially intercepted phone conversations between a corporate lobbyist and a raft of politicians and power players in Delhi suggests that the role of a number of industrialists and others also needs investigation. The CBI's handling of the case thus far does not inspire confidence, even if the Supreme Court were to monitor the progress of its investigations more closely. And, although Parliament's Public Accounts Committee normally reviews CAG reports, the sheer complexity of the 2G scandal and the number of official and unofficial players means a more comprehensive examination of the kind a Joint Parliamentary Committee could conduct is warranted.


Given the public's sense of disgust with the scale and extent of corruption, the Congress ought to realise that its objection to a JPC is being seen as a tacit admission of guilt or, at best, a certain unwillingness to allow the guilty to be exposed. The longer the stalemate continues, the more this perception will gain ground. That is why it is essential that the Opposition demand be conceded forthwith so that the probe can begin and Parliament can start functioning again. For over a fortnight now, no legislative business has been conducted in either House, thanks to the JPC gridlock. Disruptions and adjournments in the monsoon session cost over 45 hours of legislative business in the Lok Sabha and as many as eight question hours in the Rajya Sabha. The 15th Lok Sabha had started on a propitious note with the Speaker and the political parties agreeing to work extended hours and also to restore bipartisanship and credibility to an institution increasingly paralysed by political conflict. The United Progressive Alliance government with its stubborn refusal to yield on the JPC must take a larger share of the blame for breaking that consensus.

Visit at: www.santhoshtv.in

Thursday, April 23, 2009

'Star Ideas' for Injustice and the Idea Star Singer 2008: The Katcheri (Classical Music) Round Performance of Somdas and the Mockery of Evaluation

(For Readers' Comments: Click Here)

The Idea Star Singer programme telecasted by the television channel Asianet is touted as the ideal platform for budding and emerging young singers to polish and develop their musical talents and skills. The programme is claimed as a ‘reality show’, its recorded and edited broadcast notwithstanding! The programme managers and the evaluating (judges) persons often proclaim from the roof top that they are adopting a transparent, unbiased and unprejudiced approach in evaluating the performances of the competitors/participants. Nonetheless, in many a situation the ‘show’ showed that it is not at all transparent, unbiased and unprejudiced. Recently also, they aired one episode to underscore this stark, plain truth.

This note is prompted by the subjective evaluation to the hilt made by the nondescript so-called celebrity expert judge Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri and the uncharacteristic remarks uttered by the evaluator named Mr. Sarath and the anchor lady while awarding marks and making remarks for the performance of competitor/participant Mr. Somadas in his—Classical music (Katcheri) round—telecasted on 9th of April, 2009 (8:30pm-09:30 pm slot). The latter lady, whether expressing her own views or resonating her masters’ (programme manager’s) voice, made a scathing remark against Somadas, wherein she attempted to seem that she is consoling Mr. Somadas but patently disgraced and humiliated him in an ‘artful and skilful’ manner. And pontificated in a subtle mode from the roof top of Idea Star Singer 2008 that; viewers—you should not vote through SMSs to Somadas as he rather made a poor performance and not at all a good singer and viewers—you are supposed to cast SMS votes to the singer whom ‘we designate’ as the good or best singer! Dear Asianet, your anchor lady was openly treading through a terrain which was not meant for an anchor lady. Or she naively plodded through the dotted lines under the diktat of top officials of the Asianet like the programme manager etc?

Now dissect the evaluation process.

Evaluation of Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri

After the Kutcheri performance of Somadas, he remarked that the performance was a disappointment and awarded only 3 (three) marks out of 25 (twenty five). Slicing the merit worthiness of his lengthy comments is inconsequential, as he awarded only 3 marks out of 25. Everyone knows that there are two important parameters in Kutcheri or in the rendition of Carnatic music and they are the composition (krithi or keerthana) and the improvisation (including raga, alapana, niraval,kalpana swaras, thanam,pallavi etc.). So the evaluation criteria used (Did he aware of any such objective evaluation criteria?!) for awarding marks must also take into account the presentation of these two parameters. Somdas might have failed (miserably?) in the presentation of its finer details, but the impregnable fact need to be conceded, that he made at least a very basic rendition of Kutcheri. Hence the interrogative is how much marks should be awarded for such a basic level of performance? Three marks amounts only twelve percent of the maximum marks. Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri never could argue that the Kutcheri performance of Somdas was not Kutcheri at all and it was something else. So long as it holds, Somdas deserved at least 35 (thirty five) percent of the maximum marks for his performance or at least 9 marks.


Over all, considering other aspects of his performance he deserved 11-12 marks at least, from the most sceptical and meticulous evaluator. But Sankaran Namboothiri gave only the pittance. Some may argue that the authority of the evaluator in awarding marks should not be questioned but it is only a wrong and naïve notion. Awarding marks is not charity. Objective evaluation criteria should be there and it must be made public at least to the participants and the evaluator indeed has the responsibility to justify his marking scheme with respect to that. Sorry to say that Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri miserably failed in all these respects.

The evaluation on the basis of awarding marks ranging from 0 to 25 implies that the marking is on a ‘continuous scale’. Such a scale requires a high level of expertise and finesse from the part of the evaluator. The evaluation scale implies that the evaluator has to distinguish, when arranged in an ascending or descending order, at least 25 different types of performance gradually inching towards pinnacle of perfection or abyss of rendition. Note that what is needed is not the parading of 25 different types of performance but what is required is, performances, arranged in an ascending or descending order gradually inching towards pinnacle of perfection or abyss of rendition.

Simply put, this distinction of 25 different types of performances is very impossible. It may be possible for a maestro or for a genius but it is beyond the reach of majority. It is worth noting the fact that only when we are able to distinguish 25 different performances, it would be objective and meaningful to give marks like 3, 15, 16, 17 and so on. In the presence of difficulty in making such a fine distinction one cannot claim that this performance deserves only 3 marks or 4 marks and so on. If one evaluator is adamant that this performance deserves only 3 marks, then he has to explain and show which performance deserve 2, 4, 5 marks and so on. Otherwise the awarding of marks cannot be considered as fair, objective and error free.

In the context of the above said difficulty, evaluators generally follow a common sense practice of adding ‘some more’ (1-3 marks) marks to counteract the above said type of error (due to difficulty in making fine distinctions) which arises from the subjectivity inherent in the evaluation based on marks. This practice has been followed with the sole objective of protecting the participant/competitor from any adverse judgement that arises from the flaws of the evaluation process pointed out above. It is to be noted that these additional marks may sometimes exaggerate the evaluation but it ensure that nobody is hurt or thrown into a disadvantageous situation for some other’s fault like the one explained above (in the instant case the fault is of Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri). To sum up, by awarding just three marks for Mr. Somadas, Mr. Sankaran Namboothiri conveyed that he is unwilling to compensate for the error that would creep into his own judgement and thereby made an erroneous evaluation, his apparent scrupulous posture throughout the commentary notwithstanding!

Imperative for Moderation

The theoretical justification of moderation implemented in the process of evaluation need to be punctuated. The element of subjectivity in the evaluation process and the consequent variation in marks awarded by different evaluators requisite a procedure often referred as ‘moderation’ to contend with the variability in marks awarded. Put simply, if there is considerable variation in marks awarded by different evaluators than what is normally expected, that variation is due to some extraneous reason and hence must be dealt with appropriately.

The statistical tool ‘standard deviation’ is used to quantify the variation in marks. Put simply, standard deviation (SD) is a measure of (average) variation in marks given by different evaluators. The SD is computed for all the evaluations and that historical SD is used to compare the SD of each evaluation. If there is any significant difference in SD for a particular evaluation with respect to the historical SD, it would be surmised that there was an extraneous influence in the evaluation process. That extraneous influence must be neutralised through the procedure of ‘moderation’ where in additional marks are given to bring the SD almost equal to the historical SD. The table given below furnishes the numerical example.






It can be seen that the SD ranges between 0.5—1.41 for the evaluations. But the SD for Somdas is four times higher than this and is 6.18. This requisite a correction and if moderation is implemented to bring back the SD from 6.18 to at least 1.49 for lending fairness, addition of at least 9.5 marks is required which would take the total marks to around 59. To wind up, addition of at least 10 marks are required to give Somdas justice and maintain objectivity and fairness in the evaluation process.

Comments of Mr. Sarath and the anchor lady

The prime responsibility of any evaluator is to perform the evaluation helpful to ‘perfect the performance’ in future, by instilling confidence into the competitor/participant. By scrupulously adhering to the evaluation criteria, the evaluator must dissect the performance to describe where it faltered and excelled and the ways through which it could be improved. Eventually, even a pathetic performer would amass confidence and become a star performer as a result of the evaluation. In the instant case, the evaluator Mr. Sarath with his uncharacteristic remarks, virtually discharged the confidence of the low profile yet unassuming and affable Somdas by making him tear publicly. Unacceptable behaviour from anybody, however great he may be, let alone one Mr. Sarath!

The anchor lady, after the performance of Somdas, as pointed out above, disgraced and humiliated Somdas in an ‘artful and skilful’ manner. She told that, it was only because of the audience (ie. with their SMSs) that he scraped through eighteen rounds. What is its implication? It has only one implication that Somdas came to this penultimate round not because of his musical talent and skills but just because of the countless SMSs he got. If this is not humiliation then tell Asianet, what else is this? It must be accentuated that this indiscreet anchor lady with this remarks even downplayed and contradicted the open stance of Asianet. Asianet through out took the stance that SMSs sent by the audience are counted as a proxy of evaluations made by the viewing public. When the anchor lady attempt to downplay, the much valued evaluations of the viewing public as per the official stance of Asianet, she is humiliating her own employer also! She also demeaned musical wizards like Johnson master etc who gave Somdas 23 marks or so with her remark that Somdas scraped through eighteen rounds only because of the SMS support of audience.

Or what that anchor lady was talking—the evaluations of the viewing public through SMSs, solicited under the auspices of Asianet, are just money spinning mechanisms or machinations? Dear Asianet, you owe an explanation.

Before winding up, one heartening aspect need to be highlighted and appreciated. It is the evaluation and the comments made by the evaluator Mr. Venuopal. His remarks were balanced and encouraging yet pointed out the flaws in the performance of Somdas. The single word remark of Ms. Usha Uthup, (“disappointment”) should also be put under the scanner (for judging improvement?!) but well could be ignored as she said only one word!

Hence, to restore credibility and to lend justice and fairness to Somdas, Asianet must make appropriate corrections. The top management of Asianet may not be in the thick of details of the programme. Hence, the top management should take appropriate steps to resolve the issue for the future of the show.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Readers' Comments on "Star Ideas" for Injustice and the Idea Star Singer 2008: The Katcheri Round Performance of Somdas and the Mockery of Evaluation

Sankholi said... (on April 27, 2009 5:46 AM at blog titled "Asianet Idea Star Singer: Evaluation Intrigues")

Awesome Review. It is happy to see people like u thinking on such aspects of society. Please make a review on the revenue side of the show if possible .

========================================================


Anonymous said... (April 29, 2009 11:50 PM at blog titled "Asianet Idea Star Singer: Evaluation Intrigues")

Sir, Are you a lecturer? By going through the review, it is felt that you are not at all qualified to be an evaluator. You actually belong to the school of thought run by the education minister 100% marks for all! Your designation, given here suggests that you are a lecturer in the PG dept. of a Govt. College. But there are no separate posts of lecturers for PG courses in Govt. Colleges. If you are an evaluator for PG courses, it is spring time for students. Actually, the celebrity guest gave 03 marks, even though the participant made a mockery of karnatic music!

Dear Friend,

Please note that I did not argue for giving full marks for any body, let alone Mr. Somdas. Nobody can argue that what Somdas performed was not Karnatic Music. It needs to be conceded that he indeed presented at least a very basic performance of Karnatic music. It might not have gone to the heights of the finer details of Karnatic music, true but it was indeed a performance in Karnatic Music. Lastly, I only mentioned that I am a lecturer at a post graduate department.

I am not afraid of critical comments and I respect your freedom to take any stand according to your views.

Santhosh T Varghese


======================================================

Vijay said... (on April 30, 2009 7:51 AM at blog titled "Asianet Idea Star Singer: Evaluation Intrigues")


Well said sir.
From the two seasons I have noticed that,

1) they will bring 1 person from a poor background and they will highlight his poverty, his poor parents, his moderate background etc to increase the TRP ratings, This will continue this till the penultimate round and then they will suddenly realise that he doesn’t know how to sing & wonder how he got thru this far without knowing anything about singing and they will start giving gyan to the voting public as to how you should use their responsibility properly. (I really pity these guys - Sanni & now Somu, I am sure there will be some guy in the next episode as well in the same genre- Asianet really needs them to mint money & for the TRP)

2) There will be one person with disability - Everything same as above except this person will be shown the door a little early. ( the idea is to give lot of opportunities to didi to shed tears - meaning TRP )

3) The best person always never win ( last time it was the S/E ( poor chap he resigned his job for this drama, this time I thought Rahul was better even though my personal favourite was Prashobh )

4) Judges will always compensate with marks to avoid losing the good singers ( whom they think, doesn’t mean that they are always right in their choice of best singers). You should also see how the anchor asks the celebrity guest first for the marks & the actual judges compensating for any so-called errors in the judgement of the celebrity judge. Most cases you will see one guy being awarded 81 marks & other guy being given 75, even though the person who got 75 must have sung better than the first guy. I guess your SD might explain this :)

5) Lack of transparency - Sometimes they say there is a difference of 50 marks & you will need lakhs & lakhs of SMS to compensate.
I mean why don’t they announce 1 Judge vote = x SMS, and why don’t they announce the # of SMS got by somebody at the end of the elimination

6) Lastly - lack of propriety and lack of all its synonyms - politeness, decorum, modesty, good manners, respectability, decency on the part of (barring a teeny weeny number) almost all the judges & especially the anchor


======================================================

Anonymous said... (on April 27, 2009 4:41 PM at blog titled "Facts Unmasked")

I agree 100% with your point of view. There is no transparency in selecting the winner. Renjini (the anchor lady )is trying to promote her favourite contestant. you have noticed she was requesting votes for one of the contestant who done a poor performance in one episode. Whatever be their commend Somdas has got talent .so that will help him to reach heights. Anchor lady should do her job only i.e anchoring not giving commends over the performance of the contestants.

Regards one regular viewer one.

======================================================

Anonymous said... (on May 7, 2009 4:29 PM at blog titled "Facts Unmasked")

Dear Santhosh sir,

You have said absolutely right what was in every genuine viewers mind since the cssical round of Mr.Somadas was aired. It was just clear and fabricated humiliation and indecency shown to a contestant. If Soma Das were in a foreign country, he could sue them for insulting him.(I don't know if this right is practised in India.)Also the anchor lady should not be allowed in a reputed show like this if Asianet gives any value to morality for the least am very ashamed to tell that there was some of her nude pictures posted in Mallu terminal and it shows she is not more than a sex worker. And the grand finale showed that the audience of Thiruvananthapuram gave little support or respect to her. Asianet should open their eyes and be more sensible. And once again I'd like to ask the innocent people of Kerala to wake up and think before sending SMs to your favourites. Better save that money for some in needy.